CBV News

Every story built from at least two public sources

Home / Science

A Mars orbiter keeps finding hydrogen chloride over Alba Mons, and the team reads it as a sign of magma

Science Advances paper links summer hydrogen chloride above fresh fissures on Alba Mons to a possible magma body. It is a hypothesis: no eruption has ever been seen on Mars.

Science 4 min read

A gas that should not be there keeps turning up above one volcano on Mars. A team led by Alexander Trokhimovskiy and Daniel Mège reports in Science Advances that ESA’s ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter detected hydrogen chloride (HCl) over fractures on the slopes of Alba Mons, in early northern summer, at the same place each time.

The authors’ reading is that the gas leaks from a dormant magma body below. The paper’s own title is more careful: “Enigmatic HCl detections as a potential signature of igneous activity on Mars,” according to the AAAS summary on EurekAlert.

Why the timing is the clue

HCl in the Martian atmosphere normally peaks in northern winter and drops to very low levels in summer. The orbiter’s Atmospheric Chemistry Suite, a set of infrared spectrometers, measured it at parts-per-billion levels. Here it was higher than expected right after the winter frost disappeared.

The ESA release, reprinted by ScienceDaily, gives the proposed mechanism. Winter temperatures near -120°C let ice seal the fractures. When that ice sublimates in early summer, pathways open and gas from underground can escape.

The low-altitude detections are not explained by the observed state of the atmosphere or by existing models, the EurekAlert summary says. That is the core of the case: the gas appears where and when the usual chemistry cannot easily account for it.

What the camera adds

The orbiter’s CaSSIS camera imaged the same region and showed narrow, relatively fresh fissures. Some are hundreds of metres long and have colour changes around them. The authors suggest these may be mineral deposits left by seeping gas, similar to those around volcanic vents on Earth.

Sci.News, summarising the paper, adds a rough size for the leak. It reports an estimated seepage of under 3 kilograms per second, assuming the gas lasts one Martian day in the air. Terrestrial volcanoes release from a few to more than 100 kg/s, so this would be at the low end.

That figure leans heavily on the one-day assumption. Change it and the flux changes with it, so treat the number as an order of magnitude, not a measurement.

What the paper does not show

No one has ever directly observed a new eruption or fresh lava flow on Mars. Orbital images show some volcanoes erupted within the past few million years, and surface instruments have recorded marsquakes, but the question of present activity has stayed open.

The ESA release is explicit that the findings do not establish that Mars is erupting now, or that life exists. The magma chamber is an interpretation. So are the follow-on ideas about warm hydrothermal systems that microbes could in principle use.

Sci.News lists the alternative. Seasonal HCl may come from surface reservoirs such as perchlorates and ice, with atmospheric processing and burial in salts in play. Some chlorine could have an igneous origin, but only indirectly, after cycling through the surface. The authors’ preferred model has HCl interacting with ice-rich permafrost before rising through fractures, and Sci.News labels that a hypothesis.

Sulfur dioxide is the other gas volcanic outgassing can produce. The EurekAlert summary presents the HCl as corroborating evidence, and the summary says nothing about a direct sulfur dioxide detection over Alba Mons.

The check that is coming

The model implies a prediction that can fail. If the seasonal story is right, the gas should show up again over the same fissures in a later early northern summer. A repeat detection would suggest a steady source; its absence would point to an intermittent source or a one-season fluke. I did not find a published observing schedule in the sources I read.

Sci.News adds that the lack of a thermal signature is offered as a reason heat-based searches may have missed activity at such low flux. That explains why the hypothesis survives. It is not evidence for it.

Two details are worth keeping in mind when the headlines say Mars “is not dead.” The detections involve only a handful of molecules, and the source may be intermittent. The authors describe the volcanic link as a proposal that still has to be demonstrated.

ESA’s project scientist for the orbiter, Colin Wilson, says in the release that the findings “may prove to be TGO’s greatest success yet.” That is a statement about what the mission could do, not about what is now proven.

Sources

  1. EurekAlert / AAAS: Enigmatic HCl detections as a potential signature of igneous activity on Mars (Science Advances) eurekalert.org
  2. ScienceDaily (ESA release): Mars may not be geologically dead after all sciencedaily.com
  3. Sci.News: Mysterious Gas over Mars' Alba Mons Could Hint at Volcanic Activity sci.news